How do you calculate the max offer on a used car?
Start from what the car will retail for and subtract your target profit, your recon cost and your fees: max offer = estimated retail − target profit − recon − fees. For a car that will retail for $10,000, with a $2,500 profit target, $1,500 of recon and $500 in fees, the max offer is $5,500.
Your max offer is the most you can pay for a car and still make the profit you want once it is ready to sell. This used car max offer calculator works backwards from the retail price the same way, line by line, as in the worked example at the top of this page. If you prefer a percentage, the profit is taken as a margin on the retail price. At 15% on $12,345, the car leaves $10,493 after profit. Take off $1,200 of recon and $450 of fees and the exact max offer is $8,843, shown rounded to the nearest $50 as $8,850.
If the car's history isn't already reflected in your retail number, you can subtract an accident or branded-title deduction first. The result never goes below $0.
Where should the estimated retail come from: comps or book value?
Use comps (similar cars for sale near you) or a published book value such as KBB, Black Book, MMR or J.D. Power. If your comps have similar history to the car, that history is already in their prices; with a book value, check whether it already reflects accidents or a branded title.
Everything else depends on this number, so it is worth getting right:
- Comps: similar cars for sale near you, matched on year, make, model, trim, mileage and condition. Several listings give a steadier number than one. Asking prices are not sale prices, so lean toward the lower end.
- Book value: a published guide such as KBB, Black Book, MMR or J.D. Power. Check whether the figure is retail or wholesale/trade-in, and which condition it assumes.
Choose the source in the calculator. It only labels your number and sets the starting point for the history deductions; nothing is looked up or fetched. With comps, the deductions start off, because similar history is usually already in the listing prices. With a book value they start on, and you can turn off any line your book value already reflects.
How much less is a rebuilt title car worth?
There is no single reliable figure. A secondary source, CarInsurance.com (updated November 11, 2024), puts rebuilt and salvage title cars at roughly 20–40% below comparable clean-title cars, so the calculator asks you to enter your own percentage.
A branded title (rebuilt or salvage) usually lowers what a car will sell for. The source’s wording is ambiguous, so treat that range as rough, not a rule.
That is why the calculator never applies an automatic rebuilt title value discount. You enter your own percentage, based on what branded-title cars like this one sell for in your market. Typing a percentage turns the deduction on, and you can untick it if your retail number is already a branded-title price.
When a car has both a branded title and an accident, the title discount usually already reflects the damage that caused it. By default, only the title discount is subtracted. Tick “May overlap: count both” to subtract both.
How much does an accident lower a car’s value?
On average, about $500 off a retail value for any damage and about $2,700 for severe damage (about $400 and $2,000 off a wholesale/trade-in value), according to a CARFAX press release dated January 28, 2023.
An accident on the history report generally lowers what buyers will pay. These are the averages the calculator uses:
- Any damage: about $500 off a retail value, or about $400 off a wholesale/trade-in value.
- Severe accident: about $2,700 off a retail value, or about $2,000 off a wholesale/trade-in value.
If you don't know how bad the accident was, choose “Not sure” and the larger, severe figure is used, so the estimate errs on the cautious side. The deduction is counted once per car, not once per accident. These are published averages, not a valuation of the car in front of you, so look at the car and the repair before you rely on them.
Frequently asked questions
How much should I pay for a car to flip?
Work backwards from what the car will sell for. Start with the estimated retail, then subtract the profit you want, your recon estimate and your fees (buy or auction fee, commission, transport). What is left is the most you can pay and still hit your number.
Is this car flipping calculator free?
Yes. There is no signup and nothing to upload. The math runs in your browser, and the numbers you type are not sent anywhere or saved.
Should I set my target profit in dollars or as a percentage?
Either works, and dollars is the default. The percentage option is a margin on the estimated retail (the sale price), not a markup on your cost: a 20% margin on a $10,000 retail price is $2,000 of profit.
Why are the history deductions off when I pick Comps?
If your comparable listings have similar history to the car you are looking at, that history is already in their prices, and subtracting it again would count it twice. If your comps are clean-history cars, turn the deductions on. CARFAX Value starts with them off too, because it already reflects the vehicle's reported history.
Is the max offer an appraisal?
No. It is an estimate built from your own numbers and published averages, not a valuation of a specific vehicle. Verify the car and the market before you bid.